November challenge continues apace...
Publisher: Doubleday
Format: Hardback
Source: Library
This was a treasured read from many years ago, so when I managed
to get agreement to put a Sci-Fi book onto the reading list at Book Club this
was the one I had to suggest. It’s
easily accessible to readers new to SF, and is based on Asimov’s 1941 original
short story, one of the best examples of SF ever written.
Short Synopsis: Kalgash
is a planet with 6 suns. It’s stellar
orbit lasts a little over 2000 years and it is never completely in the dark. The story starts with three apparently
separate threads which converge together about half way through the novel. There is a psychologist studying the effects
of a new theme park ride through a dark tunnel; an archaeologist survives a
sandstorm which reveals evidence of multiple
layers of past civilisations and their regular destruction; and a scientist
realises that the standard calculation of the stellar orbit of Kalgash isn’t
quite right. You can probably surmise what
happens when all three threads finally meet.
Though the 1941 short story is highly praised, unfortunately
the version expanded on by Robert Silverberg was not so well received. Asimov’s short story has its major impact in
its brevity, having to be faster paced and punchier. However I think the novel expands in areas I
felt lacking in the shorter version. It’s
not perfect by any means, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. The themes of science vs religion, the
exploration of fear of the unknown and our relative smallness in the universe were
well portrayed and despite its alien world setting, it is highly transferable
to our own society.
The response from the book club was mixed, which can be hard
to take when you love the book that some people just didn’t get. It was well received by some but those that
turned up tended towards mockery of the plot and the science. I suppose we have the benefit of 21st
century knowledge over the original 70+ year old story, and the parts that were
pulled apart were the parts expanded upon by Silverberg. Asimov’s concepts were acknowledged as very
good though, which I suppose is something :-)
I read this for the first time not long after publication of
the extended novel, about 20 years ago, and it endured with me for one
particular scene. The scene describes
the astronomer Beenay handing out cameras to his team instructing them to
photograph the stars. He instructs them
not to waste time trying to get more than a few stars in each photo. Of course when the darkness finally comes the
sheer number of stars is overwhelming, and the ridiculous notion of there only
being a handful of stars is realised.
I was lucky enough once to be in the Australian outback at
night, and though I had seen photos of a full-on starry sky, it still didn’t
prepare me for the spectacle that is the Milky Way. It brought back the memory of that moment in
the book where they begin to realise the magnitude of the universe. Now every time I look at a starry sky that
moment pops into my head. I imagine that
will be with me for the rest of my days.
So, Nightfall has it’s pitfalls, but it’s still
an entertaining read overall. I would
certainly read the short story version at least! It is available on the internet and I think
you can download it free of charge from a number of sources.